India’s education legacy

For Indian students, there are a multitude of career options to choose from these days. Forty years ago, higher education choices were limited to a meagre few: Science, Arts and Commerce in high school; Engineering, Medicine, Science, Arts and Commerce in college. Law, Accountancy, the Indian Administrative Services, and Business Management came thereafter as post-graduate options.

Studies, or studying, meant memorising stuff from books and lecture notes before ‘vomiting’ it all out in long and arduous exams. Students practised answering hundreds of questions and ‘solving’ test papers from years past, with the hope that their exams will contain some of those questions, making it easier for them to score higher marks. Students intent on scoring well in exams simply crammed and crammed their brains with study material and ‘vomited’ it all out when the time came.

It was a test of memory. Students who could retain facts, figures and processes in their brains scored well in their exams. There was no test of skill or problem-solving or application of knowledge. Those students who could actually apply themselves to the best of their abilities and solved problems that mattered in their professional life didn’t necessarily do well. It was something like remembering a whole lot of ‘statistics’ on cricket matches, players and their performances; it didn’t matter if you could play cricket or not.

Image courtesy ibnlive.in.com and AP

Image courtesy ibnlive.in.com and AP

Some high school students joined the Indian Defence Services or the merchant navy; but these options were limited to boys. Since there were so few career options to choose from, academic and career paths were more or less set for the students. Nobody cared for career counselling for students or for administering aptitude tests to evaluate student aptitudes and abilities to perform well in specific academic fields or careers later on. If students got into a good college and found themselves a job after graduation or post-graduation, they considered themselves lucky.

That was the state of education in India forty years ago – and it continues in this manner in much of India even today. The marginally-few ‘bright’ students applied their minds and, with the support of their families and part-scholarships, pursued a foreign education. They, typically, chose university programmes in USA and in the UK, never to return to India again. There was a hue and cry about ‘brain drain’ by economists and policymakers, before private institutions and some Indian universities began offering new curricula and research options to attract the ‘bright’ students and retain them in the country – not just in colleges and universities, but also in the workforce.

Of course, the ‘bright’ students still left the country for a foreign education; but the new curricula initiative attracted the general (mediocre) student population into new fields of study and careers. Some of these students did rather well too. It began tentatively in the early eighties with computer education, which blossomed into a fast-growing private-sector industry before the 1980s were over. Education came to be recognised as an industry sector, a business making profits, albeit with private players building the industry. It hasn’t looked back since.

Over the years, with private investment, many professional training institutes, colleges and universities have come up. They offer many more fields of study for academic and career pursuits than what was on offer as higher and tertiary education forty, thirty or even twenty years ago. With liberalisation and globalisation opening up the economy, Indian businesses flourished, demanding many more people with many more skills in the workforce. Education became a sought-after commodity and, with more money in the hands of the Indian middle-class, many more students were able to choose their fields of study and careers from many more institutes of education… in India and abroad.

India as a source of international students

According to CARE Ratings, the second-largest credit rating agency in India, the Indian education sector is valued at Rs.3.83 trillion (2012-13 estimate), of which higher education accounts for 59.7%. A CARE report nicknames higher education as ‘the big daddy’ with the introduction,

“The strong growth in Higher Education, the largest contributor to the industry revenue, is fuelled by higher degree of specialization in course content coupled with increasing no. of courses offered and higher fees. However, the segment is facing the issues pertaining to intake of students, quality of education, employability etc.”

IBEF, a Trust established by the Ministry of Commerce and Industry to promote the ‘Made in India’ brand to overseas markets pegs the present Indian education sector at Rs.5.9 trillion, with higher education contributing 59.7 per cent of the market size. On its website, IBEF says,

“The higher education sector in India is poised for an average growth of 18 per cent per year till 2020.”

“Higher education in India is undergoing a huge change since last decade. There are over 600 million people in India, under 25 years’ old, potential candidates who would continue education, given the right kind of opportunity and convenience.”

Reinforcing this view, a British Council report released in February 2014, titled Understanding India: The future of higher education and opportunities for international cooperation, says in their Foreword,

“…its middle classes that demand higher education will swell to over 500 million people in the next ten years. India’s higher education system, originally designed to serve the elite, will now have to serve the people. Innovation and change are required and understanding that change will be essential.”

And yet, in India, there is little talk of the quality of higher education demanded by the students, their parents, and prospective employers in the industry. As far as global university rankings go, such as the Times Higher Education rankings or the Quacquarelli Symonds rankings, the existing universities and colleges in India have a long way to go to provide quality education to their students consistently year after year – and, therefore, be recognised as leading institutes of higher education.

No wonder universities and colleges in the UK, the US, Australia, Canada, Singapore, among other countries, are eyeing India as a large source of their international students! Most of these foreign universities and colleges, almost undoubtedly, offer higher education of superior quality than what is available in India; thereby, attracting students globally and from India. Every year, 200,000 or so students from India go abroad to study in a foreign university or college. This number will now increase in the next ten years.

[Citation: CARE Report on Higher Education (PDF); IBEF education sector snapshot (IBEF website); Understanding India: The future of higher education and opportunities for international cooperation (PDF – The British Council)]

Does college experience prepare us for work?

Unless we take up studies further, it’s common practice to take up a job after college. In fact, the purpose of college education is to make us employable – i.e. prepare us for work. Therefore, it’s imperative for college education to give us the right experience and orientation so we can confidently take the next step of employment and get on with building our careers and our lives. In other words, college education is expected to drive us onward to a successful life… while we contribute to our country’s economy.

While pondering over this thought, a few questions come to mind:

  1. Does college education drive and determine our careers and success in life?
  2. If yes, which aspects (or elements) of college education have impact on our careers and our success in life?
  3. Are these aspects/elements measurable?
  4. How can we work with (or manage) these aspects/elements to maximise their impact on our careers and, in turn, improve our success in life?

Last year in USA, a study was conducted jointly by Gallup Education and Purdue University on more than 30,000 graduate students to find answers to similar questions. The study found there are (quote) “critical ingredients of the college experience that have a profound link to life well-being and engagement at work.”

In an article, titled Higher Educations’ Six Sigma, Brandon Busteed, Executive Director, Gallup Education, discusses findings from this Gallup-Purdue study – published by Gallup Business Journal on their website. In the article, Mr Busteed writes (quote below):

“We’ve identified six crucial elements of the college experience that have a profound link to long-term success in work engagement and life well-being: three elements that pertain to feeling supported and three that apply to experiential and deep learning. These are all things colleges can measure and manage — and by taking action, they might not only improve the campus experience for their students, but enrich students’ lives after graduation.

College graduates who felt supported during college (professors cared, professors made them excited about learning, and they had a mentor) doubled their odds of being engaged at work. They were also three times as likely to be thriving in all areas of well-being as those who didn’t feel supported.

College graduates who engaged in experiential and deep learning (worked on a long-term project, had an internship, and were extremely active in extracurricular activities and organizations) during their college experience doubled their odds of being engaged at work. They also were slightly more likely to be thriving in all areas of well-being than were students who did not have these experiences.

It’s stunning and inspiring to know what a profound impact these six relatively simple elements can make. To all those great faculty and staff who care for and mentor students and create deep learning and experiential opportunities, congratulations. Your life work is validated in more ways than you can imagine.

But when we look at the percentage of college graduates who actually experienced these essential ingredients of life well-being and engagement at work, things get rather depressing. Only 14% of all college graduates we studied strongly agreed that they experienced all three support elements, while a mere 6% strongly agreed that they experienced all three experiential and deep learning elements. The percentage of college grads who hit the career and life lotto on all six was just 3%. We must do better.”

The article goes on to present a few thoughts on what students, parents and educators can do differently to improve the college experience for students. It’s worth mulling over these thoughts. You can read the entire article here.

[Citation: Higher Education’s Six Sigma by Brandon Busteed, Executive Director, Gallup Education; article dated 30 May 2014; Gallup.]

Indian higher education misses its mark

Every year, a few hundred thousand Indian students enrol into foreign universities and colleges to pursue programmes in higher education – and step into a lucrative career thereafter. Many of these students don’t return to India – either staying back in the country of their choice for higher education or moving elsewhere around the globe – unless it’s on a holiday or to fulfil obligations such as a family wedding or a death in the family.

What lures them there is better quality higher education and prospects of a better life that that education offers beyond obtaining an education and a degree. Tragically, India has been struggling with a strategy, a system and content on these contexts for the past 40 years. And, now, the gap is widening further fairly rapidly. The trends confidently show an ever-increasing number of Indian students seeking a foreign education.

US universities are by far the biggest attraction for Indian students, followed by universities in Australia, the UK and Canada. An article in University World News states 97,000 students from India enrolled for universities in the US last year, while an ICEF article mentions 49,265 Indian student enrolments in Australian universities in 2013. A January 2015 article in Zee News quotes a figure of over 50,000 Indian student enrolments in Australian universities in 2014.

Image courtesy hillpost.in

Image courtesy hillpost.in

A BBC news story mentions 10,235 students from India had enrolled into UK universities in 2012-13, a lamentable drop from previous periods; and an article in Top Universities website suggests enrolments of over 12,000 Indian students in Canadian universities (though no accurate figure is quoted). If this is true, then Canadian universities have become a bigger draw for Indian students than universities in the UK.

Even universities in New Zealand, China and Germany have become attractive destinations for Indian students. Not to forget Singapore, Malaysia and Philippines. No matter which way we look, the trend for Indian students to go abroad to study is definitely a progressive one.

Although 200,000 or so Indian students going abroad to study in a year is a fraction of the 20-odd million students in Indian universities and colleges today, the figure is still significant if we consider the amount of money this universe of students is collectively spending on higher education. If Indian higher education provided education of quality and substance, this money would have remained in India and helped grow the Indian education sector.

So, here’s the question: Has Indian higher education missed its mark in capitalising an opportunity that now benefits other economies?

Indian college students should be jubilant

There’s happy news for Indian university and college students – and, in fact, for all of India. According to the Times Higher Education Asia University Rankings 2014, published in June last year, 10 Indian institutes feature in the top 100. This is remarkable news as, no matter how good we think Indian higher education is, Indian universities and colleges have never been able to get into the top 225 ranks as world universities (i.e. globally) – be it the Times Higher Education rankings or the Quacquarelli Symonds rankings. And, they still don’t. These are the Asia University Rankings.

From India, the top three institutes to be ranked in such illustrious positions in the Times Higher Education Asia University Rankings 2014 are Panjab University in 32nd position (tied with Renmin University of China), followed by IIT Kharagpur in 45th position and IIT Kanpur in 55th position. These institutes precede IIT Delhi and IIT Roorkee (tied in 59th position), IIT Guwahati (74th position), IIT Madras and Jadavpur University (tied in 76th position), Aligarh Muslin University (80th position), and Jawaharlal Nehru University (90th position).

Take a look at the full Times Higher Education Asia University Rankings 2014 report on their website. You may need to fill in and submit a web-form to access the entire list.

Image courtesy qz.com

Image courtesy qz.com

Here’s what the Times Higher Education website says (quote):

The Times Higher Education Asia University Rankings, in their second annual edition, cover the entire continent of Asia (including Turkey and the Middle East but excluding North Africa and Australasia) and are based on the same methodology as the overall THE World University Rankings. They use 13 separate performance indicators covering all the core missions of the modern globally focussed university – research, teaching, knowledge transfer and international activity.

The top 100 list includes a total of 13 nations/regions and make public new data on dozens of institutions not previously featured in the THE World University Rankings.

Phil Baty, editor of THE’s global portfolio of rankings, said: “The scale and speed of Asia’s development in higher education and research is staggering and this prestigious ranking provides an invaluable and rich insight into the exciting, and rapidly changing dynamics of Asia’s top universities”.

Although this is cause for jubilation for Indian college students, the truth still remains that Indian universities and colleges are nowhere near the top when it comes to World University Rankings. A Reuters news story, Late for class – India woos foreign colleges as population clock ticks by Shyamantha Asokan, published in October last year, reports that (quote),

Despite a surplus of workers, employers across sectors say local universities do a poor job of preparing graduates for working life. None of India’s universities feature in the world’s top 200, the 2013/14 rankings by the London-based education group Quacquarelli Symonds show, versus seven from China.

Many homegrown universities rely on rote-learning and fail to teach the “soft skills” that are increasingly important in India, where the services sector has driven the economic growth of the last two decades, recruiters and students say.

“We don’t learn here – we are just taught to mug up, so it’s hard for us when we go out to find jobs,” said Singh, an undergraduate at one of the country’s largest private colleges, Amity University, referring to the teaching style across India.

“I’m worried that when I get to my first internship, I won’t know how to do anything.”

This, no doubt, is a serious concern for India’s 20-odd million university and college students. Fortunately, studying abroad in higher-ranked universities is still an option for them.

A foreign education

When it comes to higher education, there’s no doubt that a foreign education is a big attraction for Indian students. Compared to the quality of education available at most Indian universities, a degree from a university abroad is considered superior. Particularly for those Indian students who wish to improve their chances in life and fulfil their dreams and aspirations, a foreign education is a big draw.

By ‘foreign education’, we mean education in colleges and universities in countries such as the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, Singapore, and New Zealand. There are others, of course; but these countries attract the majority of students from India. European countries do feature in a wider list but, since studying in a European country usually means learning that country’s language, Europe falls short in popularity among aspiring Indian students seeking a foreign education.

Industry estimates indicate that more than 200,000 Indian students go abroad to study in a foreign university or college every year. And, the numbers are growing! Indian students who are pursuing a degree from a foreign university now say that the education they are receiving vastly outperforms Indian university education. So, if you’re thinking of studying abroad, you’ll be one among a growing number of Indian students who value quality education as the foundation for their careers.

Mind you, acquiring a degree (or diploma) from a foreign college or university is expensive. It requires, typically, anything upwards of Rs.20 lakhs per year. Indian students can seldom afford such expensive education on their own. Usually, their tuition and living fees are sourced through a mix of family funds, education loans, and financial aid (fee waivers and scholarships) from the college or university they’re applying to.

Even then, the going is not easy as most reputed foreign colleges and universities find Indian education standards under par – both at school and college levels. Hence, there’s no choice for these students but to prove their merit and worth through a series of tests and other admissions criteria. Failing which, applicants are downgraded or rejected by the college or university they were applying to for admission. Many hopeful students have to apply to multiple colleges or universities.

The lure of foreign education is enhanced not only by the opportunities it presents in acquiring better education, but also by opening up a world of opportunities in finding lucrative jobs in foreign companies – which usually means making much more money than what one can earn working in India. Furthermore, in staying back after completing the desired education programme, it offers the opportunity to build a better life in the foreign country where skills and merit are appreciated far more gregariously than they are in India.

There’s much more to a foreign education: from tough selection procedures during admissions, to the structure, curricula, quality of faculty, facilities available for studies and research, the way education is administered, methods of evaluation and awarding marks, opportunities to elect to study different subjects, extra-curricular activities, multicultural interactions with students from other countries and cultures, and an engaging campus life.

And, let’s not forget, living in a foreign country while completing a degree programme has its own attraction.

Hello and welcome to Let’s Talk by Sunita Bose

Hello and welcome to Let’s Talk by Sunita Bose!

We are excited to launch our blog today and introduce you to a wonderful world of higher education and careers for students seeking admissions to universities and colleges outside India. On this blog we plan to share our thoughts, ideas and stories which shape the future of students who aspire to build their careers on a solid foundation of quality education.

We also plan to share updates on foreign colleges and universities, on the many and diverse courses/programmes offered by these colleges/universities, helpful tips on student application procedures for admissions, on qualifying tests and writing essays, and news on events which we shall organise ourselves or participate in from time to time. And lot’s more.

We encourage you to visit this blog often and share your thoughts and opinions in the comments section below each story we post. Do also connect with us on our website, Facebook, Twitter and Google+.